CLEVELAND, OHIO: Logan Paul's fiancee, Nina Agdal, dated MLB star Bryce Harper while he was playing for the Washington Nationals. In 2015, there were rumors that Agdal cheated on Harper with Los Angeles Angels' Mike Trout, an MLB All-Star outfielder.

People always tend to compare Trout and Harper. They both debuted around the same time and were the top two prospects for a while. While Harper is a two-time MVP, many consider Trout to be the finest player in the league.

Did Nina Agdal cheat on her ex Bryce Harper?

Trout did not date Agdal, though fans believe he did. The rumors began after the model put out a post on Instagram. She wrote in the post, “Sorry Bryce, I’m cheating on you… Had so much fun with @MikeTrout @NewEraCap @Angels throwing the first pitch!”

Logan Paul proposes to Nina Agdal

After participating in a Money in the Bank Ladder match, Paul proposed to Agdal, whom he has been dating for a year. In December 2022, the couple made their relationship public, and Paul posted a picture with the caption "Lucky me."

On New Year's Eve, Agdal updated her account, adding she was in a relationship with Paul. The WWE star propsed to Agdal on Hotel Passalacqua's terrace overlooking Lake Como. The fact that the ring did not fit former Sports Illustrated cover model Agdal's finger derailed the proposal.

Agdal replied, "Yes," and the two knelt down and embraced one another. Paul immediately contacted Jake, his younger brother, and told him, "Bro, you have a sister!"